Our Pick: Leilo

Legal Alternatives to THC (2026): Kava, Kanna, Amanita & CBD, Compared

The rules around hemp-derived THC are shifting, and a lot of people who rely on a gummy to sleep or unwind are quietly asking the same question: what else is there? Good news — there's a whole shelf of legal options, each with its own personality. Here's the plain-speak map: kava for unwinding, kanna for mood, amanita for sleep, and CBD for the familiar calm — with one trustworthy pick in each lane.

By The Kind Buds Desk · ~9 min read · Updated 2026-06-11

Take the 20-second finder

Our top picks

Best for Unwinding (Kava)Leilo Kava Tonic4.6$49.99 / 12-pk

Best for Mood & Social (Kanna)KA! Kanna Daily Chews4.5$89 / 3-pack

Best for Sleep (Amanita)Hometown Hero Magic Muscaria Gummies4.6$24.99 / 4ct

Let's name the thing everyone's feeling. The rules around hemp-derived THC are shifting — federal hemp rules are tightening, and a number of states have been restricting Delta-8 and Delta-9 products. We're not going to be alarmist about it, because the picture changes state by state and month by month, and panic is rarely useful. But if you're one of the many people who came to rely on a simple gummy to fall asleep or take the edge off the day, it's completely fair to be asking: if my gummy goes away, what's left?

Here's our promise, friend to friend: whatever happens to the rules, we'll keep finding you legal ways to feel better. That's the whole reason Kind Buds exists. And the honest, encouraging answer is that THC was never the only door. There's a whole shelf of legal options that people have been using to relax, lift their mood, and drift off — some of them for centuries — and most folks just haven't been introduced yet. Consider this that introduction.

Below we map the four legal lanes in plain speak: kava (the relaxer — a Pacific island root, usually a drink), kanna (the mood-lifter — a South African plant, no high), amanita muscaria (the dreamy, sleepy mushroom — legal, and not the same thing as psilocybin), and CBD/CBN (the familiar calm-body option that's still federally legal hemp). One verified champion product per lane, what each one actually feels like, and how to pick your lane based on what you used THC for. Two quick guardrails before we start: we don't recommend 7-OH isolates — avoid them, full stop — and we don't cover anything that's illegal where you live. Psilocybin remains illegal, and we don't cover products for it. None of this is medical or legal advice — just a kind, honest map.

The short version

The rules on hemp-derived THC are shifting state by state — but THC was never the only legal way to unwind, and this guide maps the alternatives.
Match the lane to the feeling: kava for unwinding and social ease, kanna for mood and connection, amanita muscaria for dreamy nighttime wind-downs, and CBD/CBN for familiar, no-high calm.
Our four champions: Leilo's kava tonic, KA!'s kanna chews, Hometown Hero's amanita gummies, and Cornbread Hemp's full-spectrum CBD gummies — all from brands that post real lab results.
Amanita muscaria is a legal mushroom that works through muscimol — it is NOT psilocybin, which remains illegal and which we don't cover products for.
Skip 7-OH isolates entirely, go one new thing at a time, and start with half a serving while you learn how each one sits with you.

Lane	Feels like	High?	Legal status	Best for
Kava (Leilo Kava Tonic)	Relaxed, social, shoulders-down calm	No — clear-headed	Legal across the U.S.	Unwinding after work, social evenings
Kanna (KA! Daily Chews)	Lifted mood, warmer, more open	No high	Legal across the U.S.	Mood, connection, social ease
Amanita (Hometown Hero Magic Muscaria)	Dreamy, heavy-lidded, sleepy	Dreamy, not a classic high	Legal in most states (not psilocybin)	Nighttime wind-downs and sleep
CBD/CBN (Cornbread Hemp Full-Spectrum)	Calm body, settled, familiar	No real high	Federally legal hemp	Everyday calm, the easiest first step

At a glance — the four legal lanes, compared

The 20-second finder

Not sure which is right for you?

Answer a few quick questions and we'll point you to the pick that fits — from this guide's lineup.

Find your match

30-sec finder

Question 1 of 4

First things first — how do you want to feel?

01 · Best for Unwinding (Kava)

Our Pick

Leilo Kava Tonic

4.6$49.99 / 12-pk

A ready-to-drink kava tonic with a 1,000 mg kava blend per can — the easiest on-ramp to the relaxer lane.

Lab report: Third-party lab testing published; kava content disclosed per can.

If your gummy's job was "help me put the day down," start here. Kava is a root from the Pacific islands — Fiji, Vanuatu, Tonga — where people have been drinking it socially and ceremonially for centuries. Its active compounds are called kavalactones, and what many people describe is a calm, sociable, shoulders-down feeling: relaxed body, clear head, no high. It's the closest legal cousin to the "unwind" half of what THC did for a lot of people, which is why kava bars have been quietly popping up all over the country (Austin included — we may be biased).

Why a can beats the traditional bowl for beginners: traditional kava is a root powder you knead in water, and honestly, it tastes like peppery mud — most newcomers bounce off it. Leilo solved the on-ramp problem: a ready-to-drink tonic with a 1,000 mg kava blend per can that actually tastes good. You don't need any equipment, technique, or acquired taste. You just open a can.

The ritual matters as much as the ingredient, and this is where kava genuinely shines as a THC alternative: it slots into the exact same moments. The end-of-workday exhale. The Friday night where you want to be social but not foggy. The evening wind-down where a beer would leave you sluggish. Many people find one can settles them into a relaxed, easygoing mood within the half hour, with none of the next-morning tax. Leilo publishes its lab testing, discloses the kava content on the can, and prices the 12-pack at $49.99 — roughly the cost of a decent six-pack run, for something that leaves you clearer. One honest note: kava has a mild earthy undertone even in a good tonic, and like anything on this list, it's worth starting with one can and seeing how it sits with you.

What it is: Ready-to-drink kava tonic (Pacific kava root)
Per can: 1,000 mg kava blend
The feel: Relaxed, social, clear-headed — no high
COA: Third-party lab testing published

What we like

The easiest possible on-ramp to kava — just open a can
1,000 mg kava blend per can, with testing published
Slots into the exact moments a gummy or a beer used to own
Clear-headed calm — no high, no next-morning tax

Worth noting

Kava's earthy undertone is tamed, not gone
Craft-beverage pricing at ~$4 a can

Who should buy it: Buy Leilo if the thing you'll miss most about THC is the evening unwind — the after-work exhale, the social looseness without the fog. It's the pick for anyone who wants a relaxed, clear-headed calm in a format as easy as opening a can, and for the alcohol-curious-to-leave crowd who want a grown-up drink for the cooler that isn't beer.

What we don't like: Kava's earthy, slightly peppery undertone never fully disappears, even in a well-made tonic — most people stop noticing it by the second can, but don't expect soda. And at $49.99 for twelve, it's priced like a craft beverage, not a bargain one. It's also a beverage-only lane: if you specifically want a gummy-shaped ritual, look at the amanita or CBD picks below.

Bottom line: If you used THC mostly to unwind after work, kava is your lane — and Leilo is the friendliest way in. Each can carries a 1,000 mg kava blend, it tastes like a proper beverage rather than a chore, and it delivers that shoulders-down, end-of-day calm while leaving your head clear. Crack one where you'd have poured a drink or reached for a gummy.

Check price →

02 · Best for Mood & Social (Kanna)

KA! Kanna Daily Chews

4.5$89 / 3-pack

30 mg of Sceletium extract per chew — the mood-lifter lane's most polished, best-tested pick.

Lab report: Third-party testing published; standardized Sceletium extract with disclosed per-chew content.

Here's the lane that surprises people. Kanna — botanically Sceletium tortuosum — is a small succulent from South Africa, where it's been chewed for centuries as a traditional mood-lifter and social plant. There's no high. What many people describe instead is a gentle lift: mood brightens, the edge comes off social situations, conversation feels easier, you feel a little more open. If the thing you actually used THC for was loosening up around people — the pre-dinner-party gummy, the "make this gathering feel easier" dose — kanna is the lane built for exactly that feeling, minus the part where you wonder if you're too high to be at the party.

Why standardization is the whole game with kanna: raw kanna varies wildly from batch to batch — two scoops of unstandardized powder can feel like two different plants. KA! Empathogenics uses a standardized Sceletium extract at a disclosed 30 mg per chew, with third-party testing behind it. In a young category full of mystery powders, a measured, tested serving is the difference between a product and a gamble.

The chew format is genuinely clever, too — kanna was traditionally chewed, and the format means it comes on relatively quickly and gently. Many people find a single chew before a social evening is the sweet spot: present, warm, a little more easygoing, fully clear-headed. The honest catch is the price. At $89 for a 3-pack, KA! is the premium player in the lane, and you're paying for the standardization and testing as much as the plant. We think that's the right trade in a category this young — but it's a real cost, and worth knowing before you fall in love. As always: start with one chew, give it time, and see how it sits with you.

What it is: Kanna (Sceletium tortuosum) chews, South African succulent
Per chew: 30 mg standardized Sceletium extract
The feel: Lifted mood, social warmth — no high
COA: Third-party testing published

What we like

Standardized 30 mg Sceletium extract per chew — rare rigor in a young category
Gentle mood lift and social ease with zero high
Chew format comes on quickly and gently
The quality leader in the kanna lane

Worth noting

Premium price at $89 for a 3-pack
Subtler than THC — a lift, not a buzz

Who should buy it: Buy KA! if what you'll miss about THC is the social warmth — the gummy that made gatherings feel easier — or if you just want something legal that gently lifts your mood with zero high. It's also the right pick if you're rightly wary of unregulated botanicals: in the kanna lane, KA!'s standardized, tested chews are the grown-up choice.

What we don't like: The price is the obvious one: $89 for a 3-pack makes this the most expensive serving on this list, and casual experimenters may flinch. Kanna's effects are also subtler than THC's — this is a lift, not a wave — so anyone expecting a buzz will undershoot it. And because the category is young, you'll want to stick to tested brands like this one rather than bargain-hunting.

Bottom line: Kanna is the lane almost nobody's heard of and the one that surprises people most: a South African plant that many find lifts mood and makes social moments feel warmer — with no high at all. KA!'s chews are the most polished way in, with a standardized 30 mg of Sceletium extract per chew and real testing behind it. Pricey, but the category's quality leader.

Check price →

How to think about switching

Here's the trick that makes this whole decision easy: don't ask "which product replaces THC?" Ask "what did I actually use THC for?" THC was doing different jobs for different people, and each job has its own legal lane.

If your gummy's job was unwinding — the after-work exhale, the edge coming off — that's the kava lane. A can of Leilo slots into the same moment a gummy or a beer used to own: relaxed body, clear head.

If the job was social ease and mood — feeling warmer and more open around people — that's kanna. KA!'s chews are built for exactly that lift, no high attached.

If the job was sleep — the dreamy nighttime drift — that's amanita. Hometown Hero's Magic Muscaria keeps the bedtime-gummy ritual intact with a legal mushroom doing the heavy lifting.

And if the job was just gentle, everyday calm — or you simply want the smallest change possible — slide one shelf over to full-spectrum CBD from Cornbread Hemp and keep everything else about your routine the same.

Two rules as you explore. One new thing at a time — try a single lane for a week before judging it or adding another, because each of these is its own experience and deserves a fair, uncluttered read. And start with half — half a can, half a chew, half a gummy — the first time, every time. You can always have more next time; you can't take back a serving that turned out bigger than you wanted.

One more honest note on what we don't recommend: 7-OH isolates (concentrated 7-hydroxymitragynine products you'll see at vape shops) are an avoid for us, full stop — too potent, too poorly standardized, too far from anything we'd hand a friend. And nothing in this guide overrides your own state's rules: if something isn't legal where you live, it's not on your menu, period.

03 · Best for Sleep (Amanita)

Hometown Hero Magic Muscaria Gummies

4.6$24.99 / 4ct

500 mg of amanita extract plus lion's mane and CBD — the dreamy, sleepy lane from a brand we already trust.

Lab report: Current, batch-matched third-party COAs published per product — the house standard at this brand.

This is the lane for the nighttime people — and yes, it's legal. Amanita muscaria is the storybook mushroom (red cap, white spots) and its active compound is muscimol, which works on a completely different system in the body than psilocybin does. Let's be crystal clear, because this trips people up: amanita is not psilocybin. Psilocybin remains illegal, and we don't cover products for it. Amanita muscaria, by contrast, is legal in most U.S. states — and what many people describe from a measured, properly prepared gummy is dreamy, heavy-lidded, and sleepy. Not a classic high. More like the volume of the day being slowly turned down until your eyelids agree it's bedtime.

Why "properly prepared" is everything with amanita: raw amanita mushrooms need careful preparation to convert their compounds into gentle, usable muscimol — this is absolutely not a forage-it-yourself situation. A measured, lab-tested gummy from a serious brand is the only format we'd ever recommend. Hometown Hero — the same Austin brand whose THC gummies top several of our guides — applies its batch-matched COA discipline here, so you know exactly what's in each gummy before you open the bag.

The formula is thoughtfully built for the wind-down: 500 mg of amanita extract joined by lion's mane (the calm, focus-y mushroom) and a bit of CBD to round the edges. At $24.99 for a 4-count, it's also the cheapest entry ticket on this list — a low-stakes way to find out if the dreamy lane suits you. Treat it exactly like you'd treat a strong nighttime THC gummy: evening only, never before driving, and start with half a gummy your first time, because amanita is its own experience and worth meeting slowly. Many people find it becomes the natural heir to the bedtime gummy — same ritual, same shelf, different mushroom. For the deeper story on this curious fungus, our amanita gummies guide goes lane-deep.

What it is: Amanita muscaria gummies (muscimol — not psilocybin)
Per gummy: 500 mg amanita extract + lion's mane + CBD
The feel: Dreamy, heavy-lidded, sleepy
COA: Batch-matched third-party COAs posted

What we like

The legal, dreamy, sleepy lane — a natural heir to the nighttime gummy
500 mg amanita extract rounded out with lion's mane and CBD
Batch-matched lab testing from a brand we already trust
Cheapest entry ticket on this list at $24.99

Worth noting

Only 4 gummies per bag — regulars will reorder often
Not legal in every state — check yours first
A distinctive experience that isn't for everyone

Who should buy it: Buy Magic Muscaria if the gummy you're worried about losing was the bedtime one. It's the pick for people who want a legal, dreamy, sleepy wind-down in the exact same ritual shape as a nighttime THC gummy — and for anyone who'd only try a new category with a brand that's already earned their trust with real, batch-matched lab testing.

What we don't like: Four gummies per bag means the $24.99 is a sampler, not a stockpile — regulars will be reordering often. Amanita's dreamy character is genuinely its own thing, and a minority of people find it does little for them, so the first bag is an experiment. And while amanita is legal in most states, it isn't legal in all of them (Louisiana is the notable exception) — check your own state first.

Bottom line: Amanita muscaria is the legal mushroom — the dreamy, sleepy one that works through muscimol, not psilocybin — and Hometown Hero's gummies are the most trustworthy way to try it. Each gummy blends 500 mg of amanita extract with lion's mane and CBD, backed by the same batch-matched lab testing that made this brand our most-recommended name. The natural heir to the nighttime THC gummy.

Check price →

04 · Best Familiar Option (CBD)

Cornbread Hemp Full-Spectrum CBD Gummies

4.5$39.99+

USDA-organic, full-spectrum CBD — the calm-body lane that's still squarely federally legal hemp.

Lab report: Third-party COAs posted; USDA Organic certified, flower-only hemp.

If all of the above sounds like a lot of new, here's the lane that isn't. CBD is the calm cannabinoid from hemp — no real high, just a settled, even, take-the-edge-off feeling that many people describe as their shoulders quietly unknotting. And critically for this guide: CBD remains squarely federally legal hemp. While the rules around intoxicating hemp THC are the ones shifting, non-intoxicating CBD sits on much steadier ground. Same plant family as your old gummy, same format, same evening ritual — minus the high, and minus most of the regulatory drama.

What "full-spectrum" buys you, in plain speak: full-spectrum means the extract keeps the hemp plant's whole natural family of compounds — CBD leading, with trace amounts of THC and other cannabinoids riding along — rather than isolating one molecule. Many people find full-spectrum products feel rounder and more complete than CBD isolate. Cornbread Hemp does it the hard way: USDA-organic certification (genuinely rare in hemp) and flower-only extraction, with the COAs posted to prove it.

We've recommended Cornbread before — it's the clean-label pick in our CBD gummies guide — and it earns the spot here for the same reasons: a short ingredient list, Kentucky-grown organic hemp, and lab results you can actually check. Starting at $39.99, it's the easiest first step in this whole guide: if you're not ready to meet a Pacific root or a storybook mushroom, you can simply slide one shelf over from THC to CBD and keep your ritual intact. One honest heads-up that matters: because full-spectrum products carry trace THC, they're the one lane on this list that can matter for drug testing — more on that in the FAQ below.

What it is: Full-spectrum CBD gummies (federally legal hemp)
Certification: USDA Organic, flower-only Kentucky hemp
The feel: Settled, calm body — no real high
COA: Third-party COAs posted

What we like

The familiar lane — same gummy ritual, steadier legal ground
Rare USDA-organic, flower-only sourcing
Full-spectrum extract many people find rounder than isolate
Lab results posted and checkable

Worth noting

No high — and it won't pretend otherwise
Premium price over commodity CBD
Trace THC makes it the wrong lane for anyone drug-tested

Who should buy it: Buy Cornbread if you want the smallest possible change: a gummy that looks, works, and ritualizes exactly like the one you know, stays squarely in federally legal territory, and trades the high for a settled calm. It's also the pick for the ingredient-label reader — USDA-organic, flower-only hemp is about as clean as this category gets.

What we don't like: Set expectations honestly: CBD will not replace the high, and anyone hoping it secretly might will be disappointed — it's a calm-body product, full stop. The organic certification puts it at a premium over commodity CBD. And because full-spectrum extract carries trace THC, it's the one pick here that anyone subject to drug testing should think twice about.

Bottom line: Sometimes the right move is the familiar one. CBD is still federally legal hemp, it still comes in the gummy format you already know, and Cornbread's USDA-organic, full-spectrum version is the cleanest one we recommend. No real high — just the settled, calm-body feeling that makes this the easiest first step off the THC shelf.

Check price →

How we chose

Same house rules as every Kind Buds guide: the lab report comes first. Every product here comes from a brand that publishes current, third-party testing — a Certificate of Analysis you can actually check — because a botanical product is only as trustworthy as the paperwork behind it. If a brand in any of these lanes won't show you testing, walk away. That rule matters even more in newer categories like kanna and amanita, where quality varies widely.

We kept every recommendation inside the legal lane. That means real kava, real kanna, a muscimol-based amanita product (not psilocybin), and federally legal hemp CBD. It also means we left some things out on purpose: we don't recommend 7-OH isolates at all, and we don't cover products for anything that's illegal — including psilocybin, which remains a controlled substance.

Then we judged the human stuff: what each one actually feels like in plain words, how easy it is to take, how it tastes, and whether the price is fair for what you get. We describe effects experientially — what many people find — not medically. Nothing here treats, cures, or fixes anything, and none of this is medical or legal advice. It's a map from friends who've done the homework.

Key terms

Kavalactones: The active compounds in kava root — the part doing the relaxing. A good kava product tells you how much kava you're getting per serving (Leilo's can carries a 1,000 mg kava blend) instead of hiding behind a vague 'proprietary blend.'
Sceletium: The botanical name for kanna (Sceletium tortuosum), a small South African succulent traditionally chewed as a mood-lifter. When a kanna label says 'standardized Sceletium extract,' that means a measured, consistent amount per serving — the quality marker to look for in this lane.
Muscimol: The active compound in amanita muscaria, and the reason that mushroom is legal: it works on a completely different system than psilocybin and is regulated completely differently. Many people describe the muscimol feel as dreamy and sleepy rather than trippy. Amanita is not psilocybin — that one remains illegal.
Full-spectrum: A hemp extract that keeps the plant's whole natural family of compounds — CBD in the lead, with trace THC and minor cannabinoids riding along — instead of isolating a single molecule. Many people find full-spectrum feels rounder than isolate. The trade-off: that trace THC can matter on a drug test.
The 2018 Farm Bill: The federal law that made hemp legal, in plain speak: hemp products are federally lawful when they stay under 0.3% delta-9 THC by dry weight. It's the foundation the whole hemp-THC category was built on — and the rules built on top of it are what's currently being tightened and rewritten, state by state and federally.
COA (Certificate of Analysis): The third-party lab report that confirms what's actually in a product — potency and contaminant testing both. It's the number-one thing to check in every lane in this guide, and it matters even more in young categories like kanna and amanita. No COA, no purchase.

Questions, answered

Is THC actually getting banned?

Not in one clean stroke, no — what's happening is messier and more local than the scary headlines suggest. Federal hemp rules are tightening and a number of states have restricted or are restricting Delta-8 and Delta-9 products, so what's available genuinely varies by where you live, and it's changing. We're not going to pretend to predict the endgame. What we can promise is the part we control: we track the shifts, and whatever the rules end up being, we'll keep finding you legal ways to feel better. That's the whole point of this guide existing now rather than later.

Which of these is most like THC?

Honestly, none of them is a clone — and it's kinder to tell you that upfront than to oversell. The closest match depends on which part of THC you're trying to replace. For the relaxed, social unwind, kava is the nearest cousin. For the dreamy, sleepy nighttime drift, amanita comes closest to a strong bedtime gummy. Kanna covers the mood-and-social warmth, and CBD covers the calm body. What none of them replicates is the classic euphoric high itself — these are different doors into overlapping rooms, not a THC costume.

Can I combine them — kava and CBD, say, or kanna and amanita?

Our friendly, firm advice: not while you're learning. Each of these is its own experience, and the only way to know how one sits with you is to meet it alone — one lane at a time, half a serving first, a week of getting acquainted before you judge it or add anything else. Combining botanicals you barely know stacks unknowns on unknowns, and it also makes it impossible to tell which one is doing what. Once you genuinely know how each one treats you, you can make smarter choices — but go one at a time, and when in doubt, ask your doctor, especially if you take any medications.

Will any of these show up on a drug test?

This is exactly the right question to ask, and the answer splits cleanly. Kava, kanna, and amanita contain no THC at all, so they won't trigger the THC screen that standard drug tests look for. The one to think about is full-spectrum CBD: because it legally carries trace THC, regular use can in some cases register on a THC test. If you're subject to testing, either choose a broad-spectrum or isolate CBD product (which strips the THC out) or stick to the kava, kanna, and amanita lanes entirely.

Is amanita muscaria the same as magic mushrooms?

No — and this is the most important distinction in the whole guide. 'Magic mushrooms' means psilocybin, which remains illegal, and we don't cover products for it. Amanita muscaria is a different mushroom with a different active compound (muscimol) that works on a different system in the body, and it's legal in most U.S. states — Louisiana being the notable exception. The experience is different too: dreamy and sleepy rather than psychedelic. Stick to measured, lab-tested gummies from serious brands, and never forage or prepare raw amanita yourself.

What's the single most important thing to check before buying in any of these lanes?

Same answer we give for every product we cover: the lab report — a current, third-party Certificate of Analysis that matches what's on the label. It matters even more here than in the THC aisle, because kanna and amanita are young categories where quality swings wildly between brands. Every pick in this guide publishes real testing; if a brand in any lane won't show you that paperwork, walk away. After that: buy measured servings (not loose powders), start with half, and keep everything sealed and away from kids and pets.

Filed under Buyer's Guide

Thc Alternatives Kava Kanna Amanita CBD Legal

Part of Beyond THC

By The Kind Buds Desk

Keep reading

The Hemp THC Ban: What Dies Nov 12 & What Survives

The countdown guide — dates, the fine print, and the plan.

The Best Kava Drinks

The relaxer lane, lane-deep — every kava drink worth your cooler.

What Is Kanna?

The South African mood-lifter, explained in plain speak.

Best Amanita Muscaria Gummies

The legal, dreamy mushroom — our full guide to the lane.

What Is Kratom?

The honest explainer — including why we skip 7-OH isolates entirely.